Your going to have to use signals to communicate. Yelling won't work
Her shouting is to the men on her ship and to any ships nearby, and for them to deliver the message to the rest of the fleet. Also it's rather hypocritical for you to say that your song can be heard by most of the fleet but her shouting can't. Unless your singing at the top of your lungs, it shouldn't spread that far wind or not.
im not singing. The men are. And there's hundreds of them
by your song, I mean the fact that YOU stated that a song was being sung. And a hundred men or not, them singing together won't magically make that song heard by nearly an entire fleet of 300 plus ships. Do you have any idea how hard it is to sing as loud as you can without shredding your voice? These men are pirates-not actors or performers who have proper training and experience singing, they wouldn't be able to sing a song all that loud without losing their voice doing so. And again, even if they were singing at the top of their lungs, the wind wouldn't carry it to over 300 ships or anywhere close to it. It's far easier to shout loudly then to sing, and shouting will be louder then loud singing, so its still bloody hypocritical for you to tell me she can't shout an order and needs to signal when you have a musical number carry perfectly fine.
A few hundred singing at normal volume would carry considerably further than just a single man. Ships nearby would hear it; however, it would not carry across the entire fleet.
I said much of the fleet not all. And it's several hundred across 50 ships not just one hundred men. But let's get on with it
Jack what are the chances that 50 ships all decide to sing the same song together just out of the blue? These are meant to be pirates, not the bloody kids from high school musical-one doesn't just start singing a song and all of a sudden everyone else joins in perfectly in sync. Hell from the sound of it, and given how often you and your men sing, im starting to think Jack regularly puts his men through song and dance numbers. Wouldn't surprise me if he greets all his new recruits with this song here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nrj8EZm9ca8 But yeah let's get on with it
Meliva wrote:Jack what are the chances that 50 ships all decide to sing the same song together just out of the blue? These are meant to be pirates, not the bloody kids from high school musical-one doesn't just start singing a song and all of a sudden everyone else joins in perfectly in sync. Hell from the sound of it, and given how often you and your men sing, im starting to think Jack regularly puts his men through song and dance numbers. Wouldn't surprise me if he greets all his new recruits with this song here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nrj8EZm9ca8 But yeah let's get on with itok, that's actually really clever of you. Maybe this is just a thing that he's taught his crew to do, like a tradition of some kind