DezNutz wrote:As no other guard saw the older man kill the two guards nor did any of the other tavern customers speak to the other guards, the other guards wouldn't know who shot them. They could have came in pointing at anyone, and more likely would have pointed them at Jack, as he is a wanted pirate.
The more plausible story is that additional guards came in and started making demands on who killed the two guards, only to be killed by Jack and his imagination.
The older man laughs heartedly, takes a swig of his whiskey, and goes back to his card game.
Dez, you can't do that. You can't control the actions of player characters, only npcs.