OK. Then this is only a response to the forum rules.
The battles i used as evidence, even the names of the ports and players involved will disappear in 24 hours or so.
An open discussion of cheating accusations is legitimate, and any player may weigh in with the admin making the ultimate decision. after all, whatever is said will only be judged w/in the scope of the rules as written.
i believe the case i made establishes that 2 players in the same guild engaged in battles that helped each other, and that means cheating... this evidence would be necessary for in game players to make the same judgement about the validity of such accusations.
again, only posting about the forum rules, i think the rules should allow public policing of any players activity, that way admin would make the same decision it would have made anyways, since it is above the game, and for players to make their own opinions based on whatever evidence is presented.
submitted for public discussion.