I am glad someone has addressed such.
Pirate guilds are hard, however I have every bit of faith Vane could produce some more pirates in Avonmora.
The only real reason I could possibly give to why, Pirates have become somewhat extinct (Excluding Shadowood and Vane again) is due to it being easier to take the Merchant path. More profitable (With 200 ships you can make 5,000,000 a day) less risk (You do not have to run about with 500 danger, nor worry about people claiming there revenge) and more respect (I had a problem with this, however I realize now it was due to my 'bragging' in forums - You can still be respected as a Pirate, however its harder).
This is not me saying a Merchants life is better or worse then a pirates life. Merely me stating the reasons why old Seadogs have turned to the Merchant side. I am not bragging either - Merely addressing the problem, which I will be giving a resolution in the summer to the profit margin. When it comes to guilds like Dos says I believe I helped made Piracy extinct when I dropped 100 Million in bountys on Juicy - But that surely would not of affected him.
P.S I have no reason to join the pirate side again, merely stating I will help small pirates out in the summer. (Sorry Vane, you do not apply to my 'help' you rich bugger
)