Generosity

[Shadowood]

Banger is not gonna like my opinion on this. But as an old aggressive player, I would say Geno is fine as is. I have been blocked on a few occasions during a raid and I sent cudos to the blockers for helping a guildmate.

It takes an active guild to recognize someone is in need of help and for that Geno is, in my mind, fair.

[Banger]

Fine, I'll go crawl back under my rock so you all can get back to Carebear Glory.

[Zephore]

At worst, reduce the gold it gives?
Sure, it's a powerful card to ruin a ship stealers day, but if the voodoo stays on, you're still making money on it. And he'll be losing.

[DezNutz]

Fine, I'll go crawl back under my rock so you all can get back to Carebear Glory.

Sorry Banger, but Ship stealing (plunder) isn't supposed to be easy. Instead of trying to make the only method in stealing ships easier, you should have spent the effort in suggesting an alternative approach to ship stealing.

For instance, adding a chance for stealing a ship if the tail is a lvl 1 and losses a level. Instead of always sinking, there is a chance the ship can just be plundered. Adds a new approach to ship stealing, but requires the ship to be lvl 1.

[Banger]

Fine, I'll go crawl back under my rock so you all can get back to Carebear Glory.

Sorry Banger, but Ship stealing (plunder) isn't supposed to be easy. Instead of trying to make the only method in stealing ships easier, you should have spent the effort in suggesting an alternative approach to ship stealing.

For instance, adding a chance for stealing a ship if the tail is a lvl 1 and losses a level. Instead of always sinking, there is a chance the ship can just be plundered. Adds a new approach to ship stealing, but requires the ship to be lvl 1.

How about if you were only able to cast it on guildmates? That would allow the card to exist and serve the purposes everyone is saying it's valid for without allowing people just trying to be jerks by genoing other people's raids for no reason.

[Dmanwuzhere]

Lol let em be jerks they are good jerks they are giving you more gc

[Most Lee Harmless]

I protest : being able to mess with another players raids is a key battle element : I have often used gennies to that end and as a tool to control the de-fleeting of a target to benefit myself rather than A N Other. The 'ninja' of a raid or ship-theft is one of the hardest tasks and shouldnt be made any harder just to keep the instang joy brigade happy : again.

[Banger]

I protest : being able to mess with another players raids is a key battle element : I have often used gennies to that end and as a tool to control the de-fleeting of a target to benefit myself rather than A N Other. The 'ninja' of a raid or ship-theft is one of the hardest tasks and shouldnt be made any harder just to keep the instang joy brigade happy : again.

Valid argument.

[Captain Jack]

If we are to remove genos then I say we remove effect of FOJ casted few seconds before top of the hour

No, but we could move FoJ back to common status.
Yes, FoJ, at the initial release, was common!

[Banger]

If we are to remove genos then I say we remove effect of FOJ casted few seconds before top of the hour

No, but we could move FoJ back to common status.
Yes, FoJ, at the initial release, was common!

That would be awesome!