Two maxed out fleets, I won't post it all, but the last bit between the 2 survivors.

Peter Gabriel (1201 HP) VERSUS County Cork (1350 HP)

Round: 1
Peter Gabriel captain orders a new cannon assault!!
Peter Gabriel blows up parts of County Cork for 127.68 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 7)
County Cork has 1222.32 hitpoints left.

County Cork attacks against Peter Gabriel!
The portside of Peter Gabriel is hit for 153.92 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 8)
Peter Gabriel has 1047.08 hitpoints left.


Round: 2
A blazing light comes forth from Peter Gabriel and makes County Cork crew temporaliry blind!
Peter Gabriel blows up parts of County Cork for 157.44 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 6)
County Cork has 1064.88 hitpoints left.

County Cork cannons open fire against Peter Gabriel hull!
Fire spreads on the sails of Peter Gabriel for 165.36 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 7)
Peter Gabriel has 881.72 hitpoints left.


Round: 3
Peter Gabriel cannons open fire against County Cork hull!
Peter Gabriel blows up parts of County Cork for 120 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 8)
County Cork has 944.88 hitpoints left.

A blazing light comes forth from County Cork and makes Peter Gabriel crew temporaliry blind!
County Cork blows up parts of Peter Gabriel for 141.44 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 5)
Peter Gabriel has 740.28 hitpoints left.


Round: 4
Peter Gabriel attacks against County Cork!
Peter Gabriel bombarment hits the deck of County Cork for 150.72 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 5)
County Cork has 794.16 hitpoints left.

Sreams of horror and despair are heard as County Cork attempts to sink Peter Gabriel!
Peter Gabriel crews howls in agony as the ship receives a blow for 135.2 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 7)
Peter Gabriel has 605.08 hitpoints left.


Round: 5
Fire spits out from the cannons of Peter Gabriel!
Parts from the bow of County Cork are teared apart as another hit of 143.04 points of damage lands succesfully.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 3)
County Cork has 651.12 hitpoints left.

County Cork shoots its portside against Peter Gabriel!
Parts from the bow of Peter Gabriel are teared apart as another hit of 161.2 points of damage lands succesfully.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 6)
Peter Gabriel has 443.88 hitpoints left.


Round: 6
Peter Gabriel attacks against County Cork!
Fire,iron,wood and blood mixes with each other as County Cork receives a hit of 154.56 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 3)
County Cork has 496.56 hitpoints left.

County Cork captain orders a new cannon assault!!
Fire,iron,wood and blood mixes with each other as Peter Gabriel receives a hit of 161.2 points of damage.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 8)
Peter Gabriel has 282.68 hitpoints left.


Round: 7
Peter Gabriel shoots its portside against County Cork!
Parts from the bow of County Cork are teared apart as another hit of 157.44 points of damage lands succesfully.
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 4)
County Cork has 339.12 hitpoints left.

County Cork attacks against Peter Gabriel!
LOUD SCREAMS are heard from Peter Gabriel as a hit of 131.04 points of damage brings the ship in terrible condition!
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 10)
Peter Gabriel has 151.64 hitpoints left.


Round: 8
Peter Gabriel attacks against County Cork!
The main mast of County Cork COLLAPSES as the ship receives a VICIOUS hit of 168 points of damage!
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 2)
County Cork has 171.12 hitpoints left.

County Cork attacks against Peter Gabriel!
County Cork hits for 146.64 points of damage and part of the Peter Gabriel crew ABANDON the ship! WATER FLOODS the main deck and it seems that the end is near!
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 8)
Peter Gabriel has 5 hitpoints left.


Round: 9
Peter Gabriel captain orders a new cannon assault!!
Peter Gabriel hits for 181.44 points of damage and A BIG HOLE opens in the main deck of County Cork! FEAR and DESPAIR spreads among the crew as it seems that the end is near!
(Cannons fired: 30 Cannons Missed: 2)
County Cork main deck get teared apart into pieces and the ship is immediately dragged to the sea bottom!

Peter Gabriel Wins


....FIVE life. Doesn't get much luckier than that!

Wow, that's some impressive win.
Will you share your setup ?

Black sparrow wrote:Wow, that's some impressive win.
Will you share your setup ?

Well, my first ship has 9 on both round shot and bronze cannon, with the rest scattered pretty evenly, to start with some heavy damage
My second has 9 and 10 on Copper Plating and Bronze cannon to hit and try to avoid being hit.
3rd one is even all round
4th has 9 on round shot, bronze cannon and iron to make it powerful, not so good on dodging though
And the 5th has 8 on all the top four
(the sails and hammocks tend to be about 5 on all of them)

Ship1: lost to the opponent, had 54 life left
Ship2: destroyed this ship, taking 147 damage first
Ship2: Lost, leaving opponent with 202 life left
Ship3: Beat the other ship, but took 338 damage in the process
Ship3: Lost, leaving the opponent with 81 life left
Ship4: Beat the other ship, attacking first, so taking no damage
Ship4: Lost, leaving the opponent with 108
Ship5: Beat other ship, taking 149 damage
Ship5: Won with 5 life left.

Close all the way, so not really sure about how good the differeces are, especially without knowing the opponents set up! But having one that fires first in a close match in the middle can help even things up, other than that not really sure what can be drawn from it >.<

Came down to luck of the draw methinks!

Perhaps the last ship of the other player was a weak one. Perhaps it would be a good strategy to position as strong ship as last because from what I have seen with upgrades, they mostly play a role when there are differences between ships.

I think that the total amount of attributes allocated to ships should be reduced in order to have more different approaches on ship building.
Perhaps we could even add special captains (crew experience + more).

Black sparrow wrote:I think that the total amount of attributes allocated to ships should be reduced in order to have more different approaches on ship building. Perhaps we could even add special captains (crew experience + more).

Go to the suggestions forum with it